FRP | Steel | Aluminum | Wood | |
CORROSION, ROT AND INSECT RESISTANCE | ·Chemical and moisture resistance ·Highly resistant to insects ·Only needs to be painted under UV exposure | ·Prone to corrosion and oxidation ·Needs painting or galvanising ·Susceptible to galvanic corrosion | ·Susceptible to corrosion ·Susceptible to warping and rotting ·Susceptible to insect attack | ·Susceptible to rot and decay ·Susceptible to moisture damage ·Susceptible to insect attack |
STRENGTH | ·Ultimate Flexural Strength LW: 30 ksi ·Compression Strength LW: 30 ksi | ·Yield Strength: 36 ksi | ·Flexural Strength: 35 ksi | ·Modulus of Rupture: 12 ksi |
WEIGHT | ·75% lighter than steel ·30% lighter than aluminum | ·Could require lifting equipment ·1/2-in. thick plate = 20.4 lbs/sq ft | ·Lightweight - about a third of copper or steel | ·Specific gravity: 0.48 |
ELECTRICAL CONDUCTIVITY | ·Nonconductive ·High dielectric capability | ·Conducts electricity ·Grounding potential | ·Conducts electricity ·Grounding potential | ·Can be conductive when wet |
THERMAL PROPERTIES | ·Superb insulation, low conductivity ·Expansion: 7 - 8 (in./in./°F) 10^6 | ·Conducts heat ·Expansion: 6 - 8 (in./in./°F)10^6 | ·Conducts heat ·Expansion: 13 (in./in./°F) 10^6 | ·Low conductivity ·Expansion: 1.7 - 2.5 (in./in./°F) 10^6 |
STIFFNESS | ·Up to 3.3x stiffer than timber ·No permanent deformation under load | ·Modulus of elasticity: 29 x 10^6 psi | ·Modulus of elasticity: 10 x 10^6 psi | ·Modulus of elasticity: up to 1.6-1.8 x 10^6 psi* |
IMPACT RESISTANCE | ·No permanent deformation under impact ·Distributes impact load for surface protection, even in subzero temperatures | ·Can permanently deform under impact | ·Easily deforms under impact | ·Can permanently deform or break under impact |
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT | ·Not hazardous to the environment | ·Not hazardous | ·Not hazardous | ·May require hazardous treatments, contributing to forest depletion |
COLOR | Color molded; no painting needed Wide variety of colors available | Requires painting for color, may need repainting | Requires coatings and finishes for colors | Needs priming, painting, and may require repainting |
COST | ·Lower lifecycle cost with reduced installation and maintenance ·Longer product life | ·Lower initial material cost | ·Part price comparable to FRP | ·Lower initial cost but higher maintenance and replacement expenses |
EMI/RFI TRANSPARENCY | ·Transparent to radio waves and EMI/RFI transmissions Ideal for radar and antenna enclosures | ·Can interfere with EMI/RFI transmissions | ·Highly reflective to EMI/RFI transmissions | ·Transparent |
FABRICATION | ·Simple field-fabrication with carpenter’s tools ·No torches or welding needed | ·Often requires welding and cutting torches ·Requires special equipment for installation | ·Good machinability, but welding required | ·Field-fabrication possible with simple tools |